Employment Unfair and Wrongful Dismissal Procedural Unfairness

In October 2006, the case of Letherbarrow v Kindergarten UK Ltd [2006] came before the Employment Tribunal. An employee and his wife had both been directors and co-owners of the employer company. The employees wife was the majority shareholder, although she was an employee as well.

The employees marriage with his wife broke down. He was summarily dismissed for gross misconduct on 10 September 2005. A number of issues relating to his conduct were complained of, the most material of which was the allegation that on 7 September he had taken the sum of 600 from the employers safe without consent. He appealed against his dismissal but was unsuccessful. The employee then began Tribunal proceeding on the grounds that he had been unfairly and wrongfully dismissed.

At a pre-hearing review, the Tribunal struck out the employees two claims on the grounds that they had no reasonable prospect of success. From the answers given to the Tribunal by the employee, the Tribunal adduced that he had in fact taken the 600, an act which clearly amounted to gross misconduct, and that therefore his dismissal had been within the reasonable range of responses available to the employer. The employee appealed to the Employment Appeals Tribunal (EAT).

The employee argued that the Tribunal had erred in taking for granted the employers reason for his dismissal, especially as the employee had disputed its genuineness. He had made it clear that the allegations leading to his dismissal had been linked to the breakdown of his marriage. In such circumstances the Tribunal should have adopted a different procedure.

The appeal was allowed. The EAT ruled:-

* that the Tribunal had not heard evidence from the parties before reaching its decision.

* As the employee had made allegations concerning the impropriety of the proceedings brought by the employer, the case was not suitable for the summary procedure used by the Tribunal.

* The tribunal should have considered that even though the taking of the sum of 600 from the safe could have amounted to gross misconduct, the employee may not have needed permission to do so as he was a director of the employer company.

* Furthermore, the Tribunal had neglected to consider the procedural fairness of the dismissal.

Under the above circumstances, the Tribunal had erred in striking out the employees claim. The EAT ruled that the should be heard before a fresh tribunal for reconsideration.

RT COOPERS, 2006. This Briefing Note does not provide a comprehensive or complete statement of the law relating to the issues discussed nor does it constitute legal advice. It is intended only to highlight general issues. Specialist legal advice should always be sought in relation to particular circumstances.

Media Law & employment law firm advising media and entertainment industry films, TV, Television, Music lawyers, Media Lawyers, Entertainment Lawyers Media Contract, Employment solicitors,employment law, employment lawyers, employment law firm, Redundancies, Unfair Dismissals, Breach of Contract, Workplace Disputes, TUPE Transfers, Drafting Employment Contracts, Grievance Procedures, Disciplinary Procedures, Maternity Rights,Discrimination, Employment Disputes, suspensions, wrongful dismissal,Equal Pay, Media Copyright. Please contact us for advice on employment law at enquiries@rtcoopers.com or visit http://www.rtcoopers.com/practice_employment.php

Vacation
Beer Label
1941 Buick
Corona Beer
Autos
2006 Buick Cars
General Practice Attorney
Savannah College Of Art And Design
Bowling Tip
Baseball Card Value
Amf Bowling Ball
Fl Bass Fishing
Beer Steins
Rehab
British Beer
Elf Bowling
Row Row Your Boat
Car Stereos
Camping Backpack
Home Mortgage
1967 Buick Skylark
Auto Gps
Gate
The Church Of Hot Addiction
Auto Complete
Make Bingo
Cell Phone Business Opportunity
Full Auto
Adsense Discovery
Financial Power Of Attorney
Bodybuilding Photo
Games Online
Army Training
Christian Clip Art
Buick Lesaber
Mirrors
Baby Boom
Lake Okeechobee Bass Fishing
Advanced Auto
Business Plan Template
Adsense
Adsense Forum
Computer Addiction
Lil Movers Airplane
Barnyard Bingo
Bodybuilding Websites
Best Small Business Opportunities
Collegiate Baseball
Body Building Over 50
American Bodybuilding